Have you ever decided that you really need to get your spending under control, only to immediately feel like that means giving up everything you enjoy?
No more eating out. No more shopping. No more little treats or spontaneous purchases. No more fun, basically.
And suddenly, spending less money doesn't sound quite so appealing.
This is one of the reasons people struggle to make changes to their spending habits. We recognize that something needs to change, but we assume the only way to make that happen is to stop spending money on all the things we enjoy.
So we try to go cold turkey. We tell ourselves we're not buying anything unnecessary. We're going to be really good this time.
And maybe it works for a little while. But eventually, we get tired of it. We splurge on something, go over what we intended to spend, and feel like we've failed.
Sound familiar?
Here's what I want you to consider: Maybe the problem isn't that you don't have enough discipline. Maybe the approach you're taking just isn't sustainable.
You can spend less money without giving up everything you enjoy. In fact, you're much more likely to be successful if you find a way to do exactly that.
Deprivation isn't a great strategy for changing your spending habits
When you realize you're spending more money than you want to, it's natural to look for ways to cut back. And sometimes that means making some pretty significant changes.
But there's a difference between making intentional changes and trying to eliminate all the things you enjoy.
Going from spending freely to spending almost nothing is a huge adjustment. It's hard to maintain, especially when you're already accustomed to a certain lifestyle or have habits built around shopping, eating out, or spending money socially.
Eventually, you get tired of feeling restricted. You want to enjoy yourself. You make a purchase you weren't planning on, and suddenly you feel like you've undone all your progress.
Then comes the guilt. Maybe you tell yourself you just need to try harder next time.
But what if trying harder isn't the answer?
I don't think complete deprivation is an effective strategy for making lasting changes. And I certainly don't think beating yourself up when you don't stick to an unrealistic plan is going to help.
When I work with clients, we're not looking for ways to make their lives as restrictive as possible. We're looking for changes that are manageable, realistic, and likely to make a meaningful difference.
Because knowing you need to spend less money isn't the same thing as knowing how to make that happen.
5 ways to spend less money without feeling like you're missing out
The goal isn't to eliminate spending on things you enjoy. It's to become a little more intentional about where your money goes and find ways to make changes that actually fit into your life.
Here are a few strategies worth trying.
1. Give yourself time before making an online purchase
I love online shopping. Stores can be overwhelming, and sometimes I just can't find what I'm looking for. I also enjoy browsing, looking at things on sale, and getting ideas for gifts.
There's nothing wrong with enjoying shopping.
The problem is that it's really easy to do it mindlessly.
You see something you like, add it to your cart, find a few more things, and check out. Then the packages arrive, and you wonder why you bought half of it.
Maybe it doesn't fit. Maybe you already own something similar. Maybe you don't even remember why you wanted it.
One thing that helps me is simply adding things to my cart without checking out right away.
I do this regularly. I'll find something I like, put it in my cart, and leave it there. If I come back later and still want it, I can always buy it.
But a lot of the time, I go back and realize I don't really need it after all.
Sometimes I return to a retailer's website and find things sitting in my cart from months ago that I completely forgot about. That's a pretty good indication that I didn't want them as much as I thought I did!
Try this: The next time you find something you want to buy online, add it to your cart and wait a day or two before checking out. Give yourself permission to come back and buy it later. You might find that you don't want it nearly as much once the initial excitement wears off.
2. Find something else to do when shopping is your go-to activity
Sometimes we shop because we need something. Other times, shopping is simply something we enjoy doing.
Maybe it's a social activity you do with friends. Maybe you browse stores when you're bored. Or maybe you find yourself scrolling through shopping apps at night because you're tired and want something to do.
Those are all understandable reasons to shop.
But if you're trying to spend less money, it might help to think about what you're actually getting out of the experience.
Are you looking for something fun to do? Do you enjoy spending time with friends? Are you trying to unwind after a long day?
If that's the case, simply telling yourself not to shop doesn't really address what you're looking for.
Instead, think about what you could do that provides a similar experience without necessarily spending money.
If you enjoy shopping with friends, could you go for a walk, meet at someone's house, play games, or find another activity you enjoy together?
If you're shopping because you're bored at home, what else could you do when you want to relax? Maybe you could read, play a game on your phone, or find something else to occupy your time.
The trick is to find an alternative that fits the situation.
If you want to relax on the couch, suggesting that you get up and go for a two-hour hike probably isn't going to be very appealing. You need something that provides a similar experience with a similar amount of effort.
Try this: Pay attention to when you tend to shop unnecessarily. What are you doing? How are you feeling? What are you looking for? Once you understand the reason behind the spending, you can start looking for alternatives that actually work for you.
3. Reduce the opportunities for impulse purchases
Sometimes the easiest way to spend less money is to make it a little harder to spend money impulsively.
Let's say you regularly go to Target to pick up groceries or household supplies. You go in for a few things and somehow end up with a cart full of other items you didn't intend to buy.
If this happens regularly, what if you simply went to Target less often?
Maybe you could reduce your trips by one each week. Every trip you don't make is another opportunity to avoid those unplanned purchases.
Another option is ordering groceries online, either for pickup or delivery.
I know people who find that they actually save money this way, even with a pickup fee or delivery tip, because they're sticking more closely to their shopping list and aren't tempted by everything they see in the store.
Neither of these approaches is right for everyone. But they're examples of making a change to your environment rather than relying on willpower every time you shop.
Try this: Think about where you tend to make impulse purchases. Is there a particular store, shopping app, or situation where you regularly spend more than you intended? Is there a way to reduce how often you put yourself in that situation?
4. Make bigger decisions about your grocery spending
If you're trying to save money on groceries, I don't want you standing in the store comparing the price of every single item.
You could spend an awful lot of time trying to save 20 cents on a can of tomatoes. And honestly, I don't think that's a very effective use of your time or energy.
Instead, think about what bigger decisions you could make that would have an ongoing impact.
For example:
Could you do more of your shopping at Aldi or another less expensive grocery store?
Could you make store brands your default instead of automatically buying name brands?
Could you decide that certain snacks or convenience items are things you only buy when they're on sale?
Could you change where or how often you shop?
These are decisions you can make once and then apply to lots of different purchases.
Instead of having to think about every single item every time you go to the store, you've established a few habits that help you save money automatically.
Now, sometimes these changes take a little practice or time to get used to. And not every option will make sense for your circumstances.
But I would much rather see you make a few bigger decisions that save you money consistently than try to scrutinize every purchase.
Try this: Look at your grocery spending and identify one decision you could make that would affect multiple purchases. Start there. You don't have to optimize every item on your shopping list.
5. Start with changes that are easy to maintain
This is probably the most important suggestion I have.
You don't need to try every money-saving strategy at once. You don't need to completely overhaul your spending habits or become a person who never makes an impulse purchase.
Instead, think about what changes would be relatively easy for you to make and have a meaningful impact on your finances.
There's no one perfect balance between saving money, spending time, and using your energy. What works for one person might be completely impractical for someone else.
Maybe ordering groceries online saves you money because you avoid impulse purchases. Maybe it costs more than shopping in person, but the convenience is worth it to you.
Maybe you enjoy shopping with friends, and you don't want to give that up. That's okay. You could find other areas where you're willing to make changes.
The goal is to find an approach that works with your priorities and your life.
And if something doesn't work? That's okay, too. You can try something else.
You don't have to treat every setback as a failure or assume that you just aren't good at managing money.
You're figuring out what works for you.
You don't have to change everything at once
If you're feeling overwhelmed by your finances, it's tempting to think you need to make a lot of changes right away.
Maybe you've looked at your spending and realized you're spending more than you want to in several different areas. You might feel like you need to cut back on everything to get things under control.
But trying to change everything at once can make the whole process feel so overwhelming that you don't know where to start.
Instead, pick one thing.
Look for something that's relatively easy to change and has the potential to make a difference. Try it. Give yourself time to build a new habit.
Once that feels more natural, you can decide whether there's something else you want to work on.
And remember, the goal isn't to spend as little money as possible.
It's to make sure your money is supporting the life you want to live.
You can enjoy shopping. You can go out to dinner. You can spend money on things that make you happy.
You just want to be able to do those things without constantly worrying about whether you're making the wrong choices or wondering where all your money went.
You deserve a financial plan that works for your actual life, not one that makes you feel like you have to stop living your life to get your money under control.
You don't have to figure all of this out on your own.
If you're trying to make changes with your money but aren't sure where to start, I can help you understand what's happening and build a plan that works for your life.